Tuesday, February 4, 2014

Senator Warren proposes replacing Payday Lenders with basic lending from the USPS


Via ThinkProgress

I've always maintained that the USPS is far underutilized for public policy purposes. For decades now they have been hamstrung by Fedex and UPS lobbyists and crony capitalist members of Congress who hate anything that remotely serves the public interest. They could be doing much more to bring down the cost of package delivery by directly competing with the for-profits UPS and FedEx. You don't have to be an econ PhD to realize that competition among only two private firms isn't likely to get prices anywhere near marginal cost. IMO package delivery, like health insurance or internet provision, is is a purely a middleman service that should cost productive firms as little as possible.

This new proposal to get the USPS into a basic system of payments/small lending role is interesting. Under-banking is a huge, yet under discussed issue in US public policy that, along with a million other things helps to exacerbate income inequality. A recent USPS report found that 68 million Americans don't have access to traditional checking/savings accounts, and instead rely on shady/predatory lenders to make ends meet. Things like account usage fees, minimum balances, and high overdraft fees have scared many low-income Americans out of traditional banking, and prepaid card dealers and predatory lenders have been filling the gap. This third-world style consumer finance drains nearly $90 billion a year of hard earned dollars from our fellow citizens who are already poor.

Allowing USPS to fill in this gap should be a no brainier, but the payday industry is notoriously nasty. In recent years, the industry has deployed  mafia-style, no holds barred campaigns against state-level initiatives to regulate payday, and I'm sure they won't let this initiative get too far either. This industry is also very fickle- most states that have tried to regulate payday have seen the industry get up and leave instead of complying with regulations and usury caps. If there is anyone in Washington who know how to fight these slimebags, it is Senator Warren....godspeed.

10 comments:

mike norman said...

When I lived in Switzerland all transaction functions (paying mortgage, rent, electric, creditors, etc) were handled by the post office. You didn't need a bank account. Lots of people paid that way...and got paid.

Tom Hickey said...

Too simple and efficient for American "capitalism."

Unknown said...

Seems like a perfectly reasonable idea and has been successful in other countries as well.

Setting that aside, the GOP want very much to do away with the USPS as we now know it. Selling it off to their friends in the private sector. They also are in the pocket of the shadow-banking/pay-day lending crowd.

Not to mention that Congress as whole is doing it's utmost to crush the USPS by it's ridiculous policies.

The resistance to Senator Warren's proposal will be epic should her efforts start to gain traction. Congress does not act to advance the well being of the public or carry out the will of the people and they don't care what anyone thinks.

They got their 10% approval rating the old fashioned way, they earned it.

Matt Franko said...

I would point out that Bezos is trying to tap the USPS for his new Amazon Sunday delivery plans:

http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/2013/11/11/amazon-sunday-delivery-usps/3479055/

So he is trying to end run the big 2 UPS and FEDEX who are probably trying to put Bezos out of business as the internet is a "middleman killer" and all retailers (both bricks and clicks) are in effect "middlemen"... UPS/FEDEX have the logistics system to be able to connect the manufacturers directly with customers, who needs Amazon anymore...

Perhaps this is why Bezos bought the WaPo as he can trade favorable articles/coverage for political protection from FEDEX/UPS or he is going to try to use the USPS to hold them off as long as he can....

rsp,

Matt Franko said...

Seve,

Russell Simmons is big into this business.... no GOPer he I'd assume...

http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/content/10_27/b4185021575111.htm

rsp,

Clonal said...

See also United States Postal Savings System

Quote:
The United States Postal Savings System was a postal savings system operated by the United States Post Office Department, predecessor of the United States Postal Service, from January 1, 1911 until July 1, 1967. The system paid depositors 2 percent annual interest. Depositors in the system were initially limited to hold a balance of $500, but this was raised to $1,000 in 1916 and to $2,500 in 1918. At its peak in 1947, the system held almost $3.4 billion in deposits. The system originally had a natural advantage over deposit-taking private banks because the deposits were always backed by "the full faith and credit of the United States Government." However, because the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation gave the same guarantee to depositors in private banks, the Postal Savings System lost its natural advantage in trust.

The Rombach Report said...

Maybe the USPS should look into making local deliveries with drones?

Matt Franko said...

Ed I look at the Amazon drones as again trying to run around UPS/Fedex... I just dont see how they can safely do the "drop off" with the merchandise the way housing is currently designed...

Wal-Mart is experimenting with using actual customers to do local deliveries for them via smartphone app in exchange for store credit...

the "last mile" in the logistics chain is becoming a key battleground for sure...

rsp,

The Rombach Report said...

"Wal-Mart is experimenting with using actual customers to do local deliveries for them via smartphone app in exchange for store credit..."

Interesting! Presumably actual customers would receive some kind of compensation cash payment or discount for doing local deliveries. Kind of like a part time or maybe even full time jobs program.

Tom Hickey said...

Maybe the USPS should look into making local deliveries with drones?

They can team up with NSA and DHS and kill two birds with one drone.