Tuesday, July 21, 2015

Stathis Kouvelakis — Alexis Tsipras’ Anti-Politics


TINA
By voting for a new memorandum, the government and the majority of Syriza’s parliamentary caucus have not just said farewell to left politics but to politics altogether. By making this choice, they have not only disposed of Syriza’s program, or the commitments the government made to the Greek people.
They have trampled on the “no” vote of the Greek people, who just two weeks ago strongly rejected the Juncker austerity package, which was a much milder version of austerity than the one imposed by the shameful agreement of July 12. They have additionally ignored the opposition of the majority of their own party’s central committee, the only collective body elected by the party congress and accountable to its members’ collective will.
However, there’s something more than the aforementioned aspects and that at the same time transcends them: in going down this road, the government and its parliamentary majority have negated the very idea of politics, which is based on the idea of taking the responsibility of a choice, i.e. sticking by a political decision.
Recently, we have seen developments that are unprecedented not just by Greek but also by international standards. The new finance minister, Euclid Tsakalotos, for instance, declared in parliament the day after signing the agreement that it was the worst day of his life, and that while he “doesn’t know” if it was the “right thing,” they “didn’t have any other options.”
He “doesn’t know” if he did the “right thing” but he nevertheless did it. Not only did he accept the agreement, but he called on his colleagues and comrades to do the same! All this in the name of not having any other options — in other words, “There Is No Alternative,” a motto which not only embodies the denial of every left-wing idea, but is also tantamount to the dissolution of the notion of politics altogether, a notion entirely reliant on the fact that there are always alternatives and possible choices.…
Bending the knee to the ghost of Margaret Thatcher.

I think Warren was right about Tsipras in saying that he was in over his head. They broke him. He just was not tough enough for the job.

Jacobin
Alexis Tsipras’ Anti-Politics
Stathis Kouvelakis

See also, John Milios & Michal Rozworski, Ending the Humanitarian Crisis

Truthout
Syriza's Hapless and Sad Betrayal of Hope Follows Long Greek Left Tradition
C.J. Polychroniou
Since the end of WWII, the Greek left has been betrayed by its own leaders and other various populist/progressive politicians on more occasions than one cares to remember. But let's review the history, anyway, as the story of surrender and betrayal by Greece's left political leadership seems to have no end in sight, latest courtesy of Alexis Tsipras' Syriza-led government, whose first six months in power has been nothing short of an unmitigated disaster both for the Greek economy and the nation's future prospects as it has agreed to a humiliating rescue package on a new three-year European bailout agreement.

3 comments:

Kristjan said...

Greek business warn of closures as capital controls choke supplies

....He cited the example of a large company in the food sector, which applied to the committee set up to approve foreign transactions for permission to pay 650,000 euros ($700,000) for imported supplies. Only 9,000 euros was approved.

"This is not even funny. The company will be unable to operate, and they are one of the biggest players in the Greek market," he told Reuters. "How will they keep open and keep their employees if they can't produce?"....

http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/07/21/eurozone-greece-companies-idUSL5N10133120150721

They might get 30-35% unemployment by the end of the year. Tax revenues must be collapsing now.

Matt Franko said...

Tom I'm sure Warren was looking at AT that way from a technocratic perspective...

"Not being tough enough" is not the problem with AT, he studied static systems (civil engineering) and is an atheist who is also faithless (ie no true understanding of authority).

So he doesn't have the technocratic training nor the faith to get the job done...

"Toughness" has nothing to do with it...

Tom Hickey said...

Right, Matt, he was implying that Tsipras didn't know how to do Grexit. My take is that the pros broke the amateur who was in the water over his head with the sharks.